Anal vibe tightness

Hey guys, quick question. I've only been into limited anal play for about a year and have enjoyed it but my backdoor is just way too tight. I use a water based lube when everyone I know swears by as the best. It definitely helps as I use a thin, starter anal vibe. It's a Could 9 Beginner Plug which has been perfect for me using on a weekly basis that doesn't hurt too bad.
I've love to feel the purring while stroking but didn't know if you guy had recommendations for another "starter" type plug/vibe/massager? Would love any suggestions. Thanks!

• Flag
• Edit
• Delete
• Quote
• Reply